Mermaid Oyster Bar New York Yelp Reviews - Mermaid Oyster Bar New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Mermaid Oyster Bar New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Mermaid Oyster Bar New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Mermaid Oyster Bar New York
Mermaid Oyster Bar New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
20 Reviews
0 Replys |
Came here for dinner on a weeknight with two other people
Came here for dinner on a weeknight with two other people and got tapas with some oysters. Lovely ambiance in the restaurant and so nicely decorated, some of the tables are a little cramped which can take away from the experience but overall minimal complaints! Food wise we got the old bay fries, shrimp skewer, smoked salmon toast, fish tacos, mac and cheese, tuna crudo, and glidden point oysters. Highlights would be old bay fries, smoked salmon toast, and mac and cheese as they were all so flavorful! Fish tacos looked like they would have had more flavor but I was slightly disappointed with them Service was impeccable and everything came out in good time, bonus for the chocolate pudding at the end which I was not expecting! Overall, I'd definitely come back next time and try more oysters and the rest of the tapas!
Be the first to ReplyCame by on a Monday (happy hour all evening) after work
Came by on a Monday (happy hour all evening) after work with a friend. Their happy hour drinks and oyster/ clam ($1.50 ea) were great, but their HH food options were bleh. Ordered tacos (tiny), clam chowder (shot cup size, talk about tiny) for $3 each - better off ordered regular size for $10. Would recommend for HH drinks and oyster/ clams with regular dishes. Ended spending more because HH food was not filling.
Be the first to ReplyVisited on friday afternoon at 5pm ish.
The place is not too big and seats get filled up pretty fast for happy hour. So try to go a little bit early. They open at 4:30. There are both indoor and outdoor seating. There are plenty of parking spaces around this restaurant but be ready to circle around for a while... (depending on the day and time) The staffs were all very helpful from the beginning to the end. Helped us with our selections. We ordered happy hour calamari, spinach and artichoke dips, oysters and little neck clamps. Calamari was fried just right. Spinach and artichoke were very creamy. Oyster and little neck clamps were fresh. Sometimes, happy hour places may give not so fresh oysters, but this place was great. Fresh, no fishy smell Def recommended
Be the first to ReplyI feel like this is such an unpopular opinion, but my
I feel like this is such an unpopular opinion, but my therapist says I need to be more vulnerable so I really want y'all to see me: I normally don't like making reservations because it's such a commitment. I have to be at this exact place at this exact time on this exact date? What if I don't want oysters in 10 days? What if future me wants tapas? What if he wants Thai food? What if someone commissions him to write a novel next week and he needs to go to Japan for inspiration? This issue is especially highlighted in New York, as you have to make a res 10 days in advance for seemingly everything... All this to say, walking into Mermaid Oyster Bar with the res I made 9 days in advance to make their happy hour on a Friday had me feeling like a BOSS. Getting walked to our 4 top for 2 of us as the hostess removed the "reserved" plaque had me feeling like Frank Lucas. All these people fighting tooth and nail for a tiny stool at the bar to get in on the happy hour had me thinking "why didn't you dorks just make a res........" I was sitting there ordering 18 oysters ($1.50 each), 4 mini tacos ($3 each), and $10 cocktails feeling like El Chapo if he was chilling in a beautiful seaside village in New England.... well El Chapo is probably not hitting happy hours to save money nor is he in New England but y'all get me. Mermaid Oyster Bar was fantastic, I been telling everyone about it since. I haven't seen any place like it in the city. I felt like I was in a cute little fishing village hehehehe. This experience has me beginning to understand the appeal of far out reservations more and more, but still feel how I feel. I like to stay flowy. Like water. THANK YOU MERMAID OYSTER BAR ILL SEE Y'ALL SOON! PROBABLY FOR A BAR SEAT THOUGH IM NGL! IG @jnov_ Tiktok @jnov_reviews
Be the first to ReplyLoved this place.
Service excellent. Great drinks. Amazing Oysters! Bartenders were fun!!
Be the first to ReplyHad a fun dinner here! The small plates are definitely the
Had a fun dinner here! The small plates are definitely the way to go. It does get quite loud on a Friday night, but it's high energy and the service was good. Fun cocktails too. The food is good but we weren't blown away. The menu is also a bit of a strange mix of small plates with just a few large plates, so not the easiest to navigate ordering for a group.
Be the first to ReplyFood is poor to fair, over- and nonsensically spiced.
Even key lime pie is poor. Even risotto is poor. However, they know how to get you out in a hurry. I mentioned that we were pressed for time to get to theatre, and they served us 10 minutes after ordering, and desert and bill arrived five minutes after ordering.
Be the first to ReplyI came here for a double date on a Friday.
The restaurant is in the NYU area, so excellent location. It's very spacious and the atmosphere is great. We ordered the lobster Mac & cheese and fried calamari to start. I ordered the fried oysters and Old Bay fries for my meal, and 2 people got the lobster fra diavola for their main. The oysters were meh and the fries barely had any seasoning on them. Both of the people who got the fra diavola thought it was just ok and that it had way too much pasta in it. The lobster Mac & cheese was probably the highlight of the entire meal for me. It had a smoky flavor to it, which was nice, but like the rest of the meal, was otherwise not noteworthy. I also ordered a mezcal negroni and it was fine. Overall, I think this place is just OK, but the service is fantastic and the atmosphere is great. I'm not dying to come back.
Be the first to ReplyThis is my go to spot when I'm in the mood for oysters.
We just walked in and were seated right away. Oysters are only $1.50. I recommend this to anyone that is trying to get oysters and drinks at a reasonable price, they also have multiple locations which is convenient.
Be the first to ReplyRandomly came across this place while on vacation looking
Randomly came across this place while on vacation looking for a happy hour...this place did not disappoint! The Mac and cheese and the oysters were amazing!
Be the first to ReplyWent for restaurant week prior to seeing &Juliet.
Loved the pre fix menu. Drinks are delicious. Oysters are a must.
Be the first to ReplyLove this place so much.
Jose is the best waiter. Happy hour = A++ arrived at 4:30pm on Sunday and thought we would be the only people there. Wrong! Bar was already full and tables were filling in. Lucky for those that live in the neighborhood.
Be the first to ReplyAwful behavior! Incredibly racist host! Totally ruined my
Awful behavior! Incredibly racist host! Totally ruined my evening. No one should be treated in the manner in which my party of 3 were treated.
Be the first to Replystaff, food, atmosphere, again and again, just the coziest
staff, food, atmosphere, again and again, just the coziest and the best. thank you again
Be the first to ReplyStill a neighborhood staple after all these years and
Still a neighborhood staple after all these years and showing no signs of wear and tear..Lovely staff, warm room, fresh seafood...great prices ...does it really get better??? Keep on keeping on Mermaid
Be the first to ReplyWe had a dozen of the east coast oysters (east beach blonds
We had a dozen of the east coast oysters (east beach blonds & pink moon?) to start. For our entrees, the CT lobster roll and fish tacos. Everything was fresh & delicious! Service was top notch. The vibe was great. We will be going back... As a little treat, they offered complimentary chocolate pudding.
Be the first to ReplyConstantly looking for oyster HH specials and this hit the
Constantly looking for oyster HH specials and this hit the spot! They have East Coast $1.50 oysters and clams that had a nice, clean, briny taste! Also, had the smallest clam chowder ever. I'm not kidding, it was served in an expresso looking cup. So smole yet so cute! Indoor seating was completely packed so decided to sit outside but I didn't mind because the heating lamps were sufficient. Lastly, they provided complimentary chocolate pudding. What a sweet ending!
Be the first to ReplyExcellent happy hour, the drinks are delicious and the
Excellent happy hour, the drinks are delicious and the appetizers are a great deal. $1.50 oysters!
Be the first to ReplyThe service is always great here.
The servers are very accommodating and attentive. I love the oyster choices they have. It's more specific then more places that usually have only choices by coast. I've been here twice both times for happy hour and enjoyed it with a friend and solo. Perfect for a solo date.
Be the first to ReplyHad an excellent experience! Great food and great staff! My
Had an excellent experience! Great food and great staff! My boyfriend and I came here to celebrate our anniversary yesterday and the manager brought us complimentary Prosecco to celebrate. She was so nice and made our day even more special. Btw, get the lobster roll it's fab!!
Be the first to Reply